History

Is oral history as reliable as written history?

For

Oral stories preserve culture where writing was absent.

Against

Memory changes over time and details get lost.

Anonymous excerpts, translated where noted.

For

  • Oral accounts can be accurate, and beat a written document which may be misunderstood.
    RedditOriginal language: English
  • No witnesses are completely accurate, but every witness can add something to history by telling their story.
    RedditOriginal language: English

Against

  • As you go back in time, oral traditions lose their details; precision is lost.
    RedditOriginal language: English
  • If details are missing, a bearer will fill them in, adding things as needed.
    RedditOriginal language: English
Skip