Languages

Are language exams a fair way to judge intelligence?

For

Language reflects understanding and memory.

Against

Intelligence is much broader than vocabulary.

Anonymous excerpts, translated where noted.

For

  • “Reading, analysing, and then writing an essay in a target language is surely a great demonstration of ability.”
    RedditOriginal language: English
  • “They mastered the material, and they are more competent in their target language for it.”
    RedditOriginal language: English

Against

  • “Many language exams measure how well someone can prepare for the exam rather than how well they can actually use the language.”
    RedditOriginal language: English
  • “A native speaker can be bad with words, and that means they wouldn't get a C2 in an exam.”
    RedditOriginal language: English
Skip