For
It holds people accountable when the legal system is slow.
Against
It can ruin lives without proof and spreads hate.
Anonymous excerpts, translated where noted.
“Deterrence. Fear of punishment remains an effective means of deterring some people”
“public shaming is already in play in the us justice system”
“The famous principle of presumption of innocence is abandoned in favor of public shaming.”
“The problem is that public shaming has no recourse for miscarriages of justice.”